Kind of a cool deal, but its kind of sad how much New York is being developed, especially since Jane Jacobs* fought so hard to have the Lower East Side NOT be redeveloped my Robert Moses**
The great $10 apartment sale
And that's no typo.
Ten dollars buys two cold Budweisers at the Mars Bar. For those who live above the graffiti-scarred East Village dive, it's the price of a new, luxury apartment.
An octogenarian playwright, a drag queen and a kvetcher provoked nightly by the bar's cacophony are among the nine tenants in two adjoining buildings at the corner of Second Avenue and East First Street who will receive this sweet deal.
At the end of the month, they will vacate their 1920s building, which will be demolished in August. When they return in about two years, each will pay $10 (tax free) to buy an apartment in a 12-story luxury high-rise.
It will not only be the deal of their lives, but among the last of its kind in the area. Still, it's bittersweet. Their new digs will epitomize the change they resisted for so long.
"Look at this stuff all around us, all these high-rises. Everywhere you look. Behind us. West of us," said John Vaccaro, 81, the lone tenant willing to be interviewed. "It bothers me that New York has changed so much. It's not the New York I came to."
The Second Avenue he came to in the late 1950s was lined with Jewish restaurants and jazz musicians, Mr. Vaccaro said. He founded the Playhouse of the Ridiculous Repertory Club in 1966 and moved into his 2,100-square-foot loft 11 years later.
By then the building, once a Yiddish theater, had been seized by the city, as had many others after arsonists-for-hire torched much of the neighborhood. Artists like Mr. Vaccaro reclaimed the abandoned buildings. Eventually, with government subsidies, they were brought up to code and returned to the tax rolls.
Tenants' sweat equity and sheer perseverance were rewarded as the city disposed itself of its portfolio. Many were allowed to buy their units for a nominal fee. Developers, meanwhile, salvaged city-owned buildings and parking lots. Some erected luxury apartments.
But like the walls of the Mars Bar, the blank canvas that once attracted artists to the neighborhood has been covered. Almost no formerly city-owned buildings remain undeveloped.
"It's the end of an era," said Steve Herrick, executive director of the Cooper Square Committee, a community housing organization.
The city Department of Housing Preservation and Development owns fewer than 800 apartments acquired through tax foreclosure, down from 101,000 in 1981.
The last resident-occupied, city-owned building on the Lower East Side is 400 Grand St., Mr. Herrick said. It is part of a 10-parcel, 7-acre site, the largest undeveloped city-owned plot south of 96th Street, to be developed into 1,000 mixed-income units in the next few years.
In the Cooper Square Urban Renewal Area, from the Bowery to Second Avenue and from East Fifth to Stanton streets, one piece of vacant, city-owned land remains: a tiny lot off East Houston Street.
East Village evolution
The area was designated for renewal in 1959, but residents stopped Robert Moses' plans to raze blocks and create a development like Stuyvesant Town on the Lower East Side. Instead, the neighborhood was developed piecemeal.
The final installment came in the last decade, when developer Avalon Bay Communities built four luxury buildings. Whole Foods Market moved into one on East Houston Street in 2007. The other developments surround Mr. Vaccaro's building, 11-17 Second Ave., which the city sold to BFC Partners in 2002. The same year, 9 Second Ave. was sold to the Urban Homesteading Assistance Board, a housing organization.
The tenants in those two buildings will be among the last in the area to get their apartments for next to nothing. But there is a twist.
With a 1,261-square-foot, two-bedroom across the street renting for $7,955 a month, government subsidies are not needed. It is more economical to build a new building and use market-rate rentals to subsidize free apartments for the tenants than to rehabilitate their five- and three-story structures.
"The neighborhood went from arson to devastation to landlord abandonment to development, where the profits of market-rate housing are strong enough to throw off a little surplus and make some units of affordable housing possible at really no cost to government," said Richard Heitler, chief operating officer of UHAB. "It's a win-win-win."
In the new, 65-unit building, nine of the 13 affordable apartments will go to the tenants in the existing buildings. The other four will be sold by lottery for around $150,000 to people making less than $64,000, according to BFC Partners.
Donald Capoccia, a principal at BFC, said his company was among the first to rehabilitate city-owned property. It renovated 72 E. Third St. in 1980 after acquiring the building for $1. The company grew. More recently, it developed the high-rise Toren condominium in downtown Brooklyn.
"We did probably one of the first ones under the Koch administration," Mr. Capoccia said. "Now, we're doing one of the last ones."
Yuppie scum
Neighborhood blogs have covered the story with the requisite antipathy for yuppie scum. Locals have mostly lamented that the Mars Bar will come down with the building, but the protests of earlier years have given way to resignation. At a February City Planning Commission hearing, no one spoke in opposition.
"The bar's closing. Oh, well," said a Mars Bar bartender named Amy. "You move on. I dislike this neighborhood now."
Mr. Vaccaro, like his building, is old and frail. "I'd rather be young and directing shows," he said while sifting through memorabilia he is giving away. He pays $294 a month but has spent thousands renovating his space.
His kitchen, though, sits on a platform because the floor is unstable. Illuminated by track lighting, it could be the set of one of his plays, with Mr. Vaccaro playing the character who doesn't recognize the neighborhood he calls home.
"I don't know who these people are," he said, motioning to the street below his second-floor loft.
But he knows a good deal when he sees it. "They're giving me a two-bedroom apartment," he said. "That sounds fab."
*Her book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, is a great read and has had much impact on urban renewal and reactions against urban development since its publication in the 60s
**More to come on Robert Moses (and Jane Jacobs) later, but basically he was one of the big shapers and planners of modern American cities
No comments:
Post a Comment